Hearing two sides of a story brings a softening
Questions / Réponses
Extraits marquants
- When we listen to the others, we develop a softening attitude toward them.
Résumé
What happen when you bring a Palestinian and Israeli to talk to UK students?
Sous-titres
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.264 --> 00:00:03.116
The vast majority of the
students it is the first time
2
00:00:03.141 --> 00:00:05.164
that they have met
someone Israeli
3
00:00:05.189 --> 00:00:07.234
and or someone Palestinian.
4
00:00:08.362 --> 00:00:11.828
So for them it's definitely
a transforming experience.
5
00:00:11.853 --> 00:00:14.305
And one of the main
reasons for this is because
6
00:00:14.330 --> 00:00:18.963
all of us of course over here
mainly see information about
7
00:00:18.988 --> 00:00:21.346
the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict in the news
8
00:00:21.371 --> 00:00:23.830
in the media and on social media.
9
00:00:23.855 --> 00:00:26.869
And that's inevitably limiting
10
00:00:26.894 --> 00:00:29.229
and pretty much every
media outlet
11
00:00:29.254 --> 00:00:32.838
whether it's mainstream or social
media has some kind of opinions.
12
00:00:32.863 --> 00:00:34.877
It has some kind of bias.
13
00:00:34.902 --> 00:00:37.902
In social media people tend
to be in this echo chamber
14
00:00:37.927 --> 00:00:39.338
on Twitter or whatever where
15
00:00:39.363 --> 00:00:42.244
or on Facebook where they have
their friends who agree with what
16
00:00:42.269 --> 00:00:45.595
they already think
or posting the same information
17
00:00:45.620 --> 00:00:47.517
which reinforces what
they were already thinking.
18
00:00:47.542 --> 00:00:49.181
So you've got that element.
19
00:00:49.206 --> 00:00:50.658
And then you've got
the mainstream media
20
00:00:50.683 --> 00:00:52.580
who depending on if they're
left wing or right wing
21
00:00:52.605 --> 00:00:54.408
and this is what I mean by
22
00:00:54.433 --> 00:00:58.119
people making this issue not necessarily
really about Israel Palestine
23
00:00:58.144 --> 00:01:00.605
but about their own worldview
24
00:01:00.630 --> 00:01:03.588
whether it be left wing
or right wing or whatever.
25
00:01:03.613 --> 00:01:05.377
So you see the mainstream media
26
00:01:05.402 --> 00:01:07.798
pushing more of a left wing
approach or right wing approach
27
00:01:07.823 --> 00:01:09.970
using this issue as a badge of like
28
00:01:09.995 --> 00:01:13.539
a credential for their
political positioning.
29
00:01:14.123 --> 00:01:16.643
And this is the prism that
all these young people see
30
00:01:16.668 --> 00:01:18.052
the issue through.
31
00:01:18.084 --> 00:01:20.313
So then they meet ordinary people
32
00:01:20.338 --> 00:01:22.821
who talk about their
childhoods and talk about
33
00:01:22.846 --> 00:01:25.196
growing up just like them but
obviously with some differences
34
00:01:25.229 --> 00:01:29.727
that need to be addressed for
the future in terms of the conflict.
35
00:01:29.752 --> 00:01:34.157
And the other it's just a whole
new experience for them.
36
00:01:34.182 --> 00:01:36.430
What we tend to see is that
if people come in
37
00:01:36.455 --> 00:01:38.391
supporting one side against the other
38
00:01:38.416 --> 00:01:40.227
thinking basically there's
one side that's got to win,
39
00:01:40.252 --> 00:01:43.079
the other side should lose,
one side's right, one side's wrong,
40
00:01:43.104 --> 00:01:48.311
they tend to come out of the
session questioning that idea.
41
00:01:48.336 --> 00:01:50.852
They see it more,
there's a humanizing element
42
00:01:50.877 --> 00:01:53.841
to the session which helps them
to see it more as ordinary people
43
00:01:53.866 --> 00:01:55.334
not just armies and governments.
44
00:01:55.359 --> 00:01:57.829
But we've had a lot on our
feedback forms we use,
45
00:01:57.854 --> 00:02:00.212
we have a lot of response
from students saying you know
46
00:02:00.237 --> 00:02:02.699
I'm still more pro this
47
00:02:02.724 --> 00:02:04.633
but I'm where I've heard
the other side now.
48
00:02:04.658 --> 00:02:07.615
I'm willing to listen to the other
side, that kind of softening attitude.
content.front.transcript_toggle
The vast majority of the students it is the first time that they have met someone Israeli and or someone Palestinian. So for them it's definitely a transforming experience. And one of the main reasons for this is because all of us of course over here mainly see information about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the news in the media and on social media. And that's inevitably limiting and pretty much every media outlet whether it's mainstream or social media has some kind of opinions. It has some kind of bias. In social media people tend to be in this echo chamber on Twitter or whatever where or on Facebook where they have their friends who agree with what they already think or posting the same information which reinforces what they were already thinking. So you've got that element. And then you've got the mainstream media who depending on if they're left wing or right wing and this is what I mean by people making this issue not necessarily really about Israel Palestine but about their own worldview whether it be left wing or right wing or whatever. So you see the mainstream media pushing more of a left wing approach or right wing approach using this issue as a badge of like a credential for their political positioning. And this is the prism that all these young people see the issue through. So then they meet ordinary people who talk about their childhoods and talk about growing up just like them but obviously with some differences that need to be addressed for the future in terms of the conflict. And the other it's just a whole new experience for them. What we tend to see is that if people come in supporting one side against the other thinking basically there's one side that's got to win, the other side should lose, one side's right, one side's wrong, they tend to come out of the session questioning that idea. They see it more, there's a humanizing element to the session which helps them to see it more as ordinary people not just armies and governments. But we've had a lot on our feedback forms we use, we have a lot of response from students saying you know I'm still more pro this but I'm where I've heard the other side now. I'm willing to listen to the other side, that kind of softening attitude.